The most popular network equipment monitoring systems distributed under license GPL – Cacti, Nagios, Zabbix are considered. Similarities and differences between them are revealed. The architecture and main components of the monitoring system are described. The working full-functional state of each considered system is modeled. Critical disadvantages of the compared monitoring systems are given. It is noted that due to the identifi ed shortcomings and the need to use a large number of third-party plugins for Cacti and Nagios, as well as due to the complexity of scaling these systems, Zabbix system is recognized as the best choice for monitoring a large number of metrics.
monitoring, Cacti, Nagios, Zabbix, Docker, alert manager, metrics, notifi cations, GPL, RRDTool
1. Noskova A. I., Tokranova M. V. Obzor avtomatizirovannyh sistem monitoringa // Intellektual'nye tehnologii na transporte. 2017. № 1. S. 42-47.
2.
3. Osnovy monitoringa i sbora metrik. URL: https://www.8host.com/blog/osnovy-monitoringa-i-sbora-metrik.
4.
5. Shmelev V. V. Metod monitoringa tehnologicheskih processov na osnove strukturno-logicheskogo podhoda // Intellektual'nye tehnologii na transporte. 2017. № 2. S. 5-14.
6.
7. Jones D. Creating Unifi ed IT Monitoring and Management in Your Environment. – Realtime Publishers, 2012. – 92 p.
8.
9. Croll A. Complete Web Monitoring. – Sean Power: O’Reilly Media, 2009. 672 p.
10.
11. Vacche A. D., Lee S. K. Zabbix Mastering. – Packt Publishing Ltd., 2013. 358 p.
12.
13. Linikova O. E. Monitoring servernogo oborudovaniya i prilozheniy. – Ekaterinburg, 2014. 123 s.
14.
15. Graphite – kak postroit' million grafikov. URL: https://events.yandex.ru/lib/talks/1122.
16.
17. Vladyshev A. Zabbix i milliony metrik: nailuchshiy opyt masshtabnogo monitoringa. URL: http://www.highload.ru/2015/abstracts/1965.html.
18.
19. Analiz sistem centralizovannogo monitoringa s otkrytym ishodnym kodom monitoringa. URL: https://sites.google.com/site/teachingandresearchwork/sravnenie-sredstvmonitoringa.
20.
21. Pyat' klyuchevyh funkciy sistem monitoringa proizvoditel'nosti seti. URL: https://networkguru.ru/piatcliuchevykh-funktcii-sistem-monitoringa-proizvoditelnosti-seti.
22.
23. Ispol'zovanie Zabbix dlya monitoringa kriticheskih sistem. URL: https://xakep.ru/2014/08/13/using-zabbix.
24.
25. Setevaya i servernaya statistika s ispol'zovaniem Cacti. URL: https://nsrc.org/workshops/2014/caren-nsrc-dante/raw-attachment/wiki/Agenda/cacti-from-packages-vRU.pdf.
26.
27. Monitoring komp'yuternoy seti ili testirovanie sistem monitoringa. URL: https://united.net.ua/?id=usage&text=3.
28.
29. Nagios vs Zabbix – cravnenie sistem monitoringa seti. URL: http://amigosteam.ru/blog/item/12-nagios-vs-zabbix.
